Medicare Supplemental Help

We are your employee when it comes to your Medicare Supplement Coverage. We value your business and your feedback on how we can do even better in the future.

Today there seems to be more and more agents in the insurance industry that are only concerned with making money, with no regard to their clients well-being. Medicare65 is owned and operated by Nevin and Witt Insurance Services. We have been helping seniors across the country for over 70 years and we truly believe that our clients needs are the #1 concern for us. If we can help our clients get covered with the best protection for them, the financial rewards will follow.

Our Mission at Medicare65 is placing the client with the best coverage, ensuring they fully understand how they are protected and with the best value. We teach our employees to guide you through the process and be the best advocate possible for you. Now and into the future

More about us

Understanding your Medicare choices:

Providers You Can Trust

Part D

Free Part D Consultation

Get Prescription Help

Instant Quotes

One Simple Step to Compare Plans
  • Easy Online or Over the Phone Application
  • Free Quotes
  • Secure Process
  • No Obligation
  • Friendly Informed Agents
  • 100% Customer Satisfaction
Get Prescription Help

Request Forms

Request Forms by State

Request Here
Our Clients Speak

It is rare to get this
level of service these days

If you are looking for a reliable, knowledgeable and patient agent to help you understand the “Medicare Maze”, look no further!

Julia Hughes of Nevin and Witt was referred to me when my partner and I began the Medicare process. Not only does Julia know Medicare inside and out, she is consistently responsive to any questions or concerns I have. She also knew the best suggestions for Supplemental plans and Part D. The customer support team for any claim issues is also top-notch and extremely responsive as well.

I’m very grateful for the Nevin & Witt team – Julia, Stephanie, Sharon and Tyler.

- Diane D.

My wife and I worked with Julia Hughes of Nevin and Witt for our medical insurance once we reached Medicare age in fall 2019. Julia has worked diligently on our behalf to secure the best value for the money and we have been very happy with our health insurance policies. Julia responds very quickly to emails and phone calls and, most importantly, on a personal level has been extremely gracious and patient with our multitude of questions as we enter into the confusing world of Medicare and the various plans associated. I highly recommend using Julia and Nevin and Witt for your medical insurance needs.

- Jeff C.

Anyone who’s had to undertake Medicare options understand the bewilderment one faces with the mountain of mail that floods you once you reach the qualifying age.

It is in this sea of turmoil I would like to acknowledge Julie Hughes’ superlative service. No question was too much for her, and I posed many questions, in trying to swim through this maze of options that bombarded me from multiple vendors on the best choice for my Medicare needs.

Julia walked me through the myriad of plans / options and took the time to explain the benefits available to me, so that I could make an informed decision on a program that was best suited for my needs.

Her exceptional attitude and jovial personality deserves recognition. I wish to extend my heartfelt gratitude and thanks for the service she extended that went beyond expectation. She’s awesome !!

- Ed M.

If I could give more than 5 stars I would
I broke my ankle in 3 places and had to have surgery in September 2021 . A week or so after appointment with the ortho doctor the incision had opened back up and very painful called for appointment and was told ortho couldn’t see me anymore due to my insurance so after a few very painful weeks wound not getting better, I reached out to Julia at Nevin & Witt just yesterday . This morning Shana from there office called me to let me know all was good and ortho office would be calling to see me . I seriously am AMAZED at the quick response to my needs, the above and beyond attention that Julia and Shana gave me. If anyone struggling with understanding medical insurance in’s and out’s save a lot of stress and worry by having the PRO’S at Nevin & Witt help with any insurance needs you may have. Thank you so very much Shana & Julia

- Lisa M.

I’ve worked with Amber for over 10 years. She was a great help in leading me through the tangles of the various MediGap options when I started Medicare. She helped find the appropriate policy for my mother-in-law. She has helped my wife through the vagaries of ObamaCare, faith-based policies and standard individual policies. Amber is patient with my questions, persistent in looking for solutions and always makes sure our needs are met. Recently she came up with a plan that provided more coverage than the one I had, and cost less. She also found a way to make the change outside of the normal time periods. She Rocks!

- Murry S.

I want to thank Amber at Nevin and Witt for her kindness and persistence in navigating the Medicare system and secondary insurances offered. Without her professional assistance I would be lost and confused by the if and or buts that are thrown at you trying to search out what is workable! Amber made this process a very understandable and it didn’t take long.
The receptionist has a wonderful phone voice too.

- P.B.

Now this is the company you want to help all your family Insurance needs from their team that helps with Medicare to Car insurance I wouldnt go anywhere else. Tyler Walsh was so kind during Open enrollment helping my grandmother find the right plan for her and even double checking her Supplement when the right time of year came. They treat you like family!

- Nicole M.

“Thank you Nevin & Witt for helping me find a better price for my medicare insurance needs. I will be referring you to all of my friends”

- Janell

“Thank you so much for your help in the Medicare Supplement sign-up process. I am now on my “Medicare” road with a strong policy foundation.”

- Jessica

“I want to be sure that the management at Nevin & Witt are aware of how wonderful and helpful Catherine has been for me and now my wife. I know nothing about this side of the insurance business, especially the ins and outs of medicare. Catherine has helped me to select the very best options for my wife and I. She is an extremely patient, knowledgeable woman and an asset to your company! I was a VP of Underwriting for 42 years retiring from Kemper and in my years, I recognized that there are two kinds of people that work for a living…those with a job and those with a career. Catherine has a chosen to make this a career and her work shows it!

Thank you!”

- William L

“Your help made my day, it helped take that last step away from the insurance work had provided us. It had become so expensive. You are really good and your job and they should give you a big ole raise and time off for good behavior.”

- Paula Harper

“Dear Jessica,

I made you something just to show you my gratitude to you for making an extremely confusing and frustrating time into order and possible!

Thank you for leading – your insight and knowledge – and especially for the fun we’ve shared along this confusing and bumpy journey. You’ve made me feel as if I were never alone! God bless, you really are special!”

- Lois
Medicare Supplements

Medicare Supplements is a Medigap policy. It is insurance sold by private insurance companies to fill “gaps” in your current coverage. Medigap policies help pay some of the health care costs that your Original Medicare Plan doesn’t cover. If you are in an Original Medicare Plan and have a Medigap policy, then Medicare and Medigap will each pay their shares of covered costs.

Medicare65 Agents are Different
  • We encourage our agents to spend as much time as they need to educate you.
  • We ensure you understand how Medicare and Medicare supplements work together.
  • We’ll also explain the differences in benefits between Medicare supplement plan letter and the pricing offered by each company.

why choose us

Decades of experience working for you.

Insurance solutions for all needs and budgets.

Professionals who seek to first understand your needs.

We promise to treat you right, every time.

Full time customer service to deal with any questions.

Our reward is earning your trust.